| Game Date | Winner | Result | Detail | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 25, 1986 | Germantown | 2-1 | Game 2 | Bracket |
| Oct. 27, 1990 | Germantown | 2-1 | Game 6 | Bracket |
| Oct. 25, 1991 | Father Ryan | 2-1 | Bracket | |
| Oct. 31, 1992 | Father Ryan | 2-0 | Bracket | |
| Oct. 28, 1993 | Father Ryan | 2-0 | Bracket | |
| Oct. 24, 1996 | Father Ryan | 2-0 | Bracket |