| Game Date | Winner | Result | Detail | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 23, 1962 | Boehm | - | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 23, 1962 | Lucas | 8-6 | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Mar. 1, 1963 | Ehlinger | - | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Mar. 7, 1964 | Williams | - | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 13, 1965 | Farmer | - | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 17, 1967 | Alford | 2-1 | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 16, 1968 | Brown | 7-1 | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 16, 1968 | Mara | 3-1 | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 21, 1970 | Martin Francis | 6-2 | Game 0 | Bracket |
| Feb. 21, 1970 | DeCosimo | 10-2 | Game 0 | Bracket |