| Year | Class | Team Runner-Up | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Div. II AAA | Father Ryan (11-5) | 31-38 | Franklin |
| 2024 | Div. II A-AA | Boyd Buchanan | 30-42 | Franklin |
| 2024 | Class AA | Knoxville Halls (18-7) | 36-38 | Franklin |
| 2024 | Class A | Tullahoma (26-8) | 16-44 | Franklin |
| 2023 | Div. II AAA | Baylor (11-2) | 28-33 | Franklin |
| 2023 | Div. II A-AA | Lakeway Christian (9-2) | 28-33 | Franklin |
| 2023 | Class AA | Bradley Central (19-6) | 27-36 | Franklin |
| 2023 | Class A | Signal Mountain (21-3) | 35-36 | Franklin |
| 2022 | Class A | Greeneville (17-1) | 36-39 | Franklin |
| 2022 | Div. II AAA | Father Ryan (25-5) | 21-36 | Franklin |
| 2022 | Div. II A-AA | Chattanooga Christian (20-8) | 30-45 | Franklin |
| 2022 | Class AA | Bradley Central (15-5) | 28-34 | Franklin |
| 2021 | Class A-AA | Pigeon Forge (25-6) | 36-39 | Franklin |
| 2021 | Class AAA | Wilson Central (30-1) | 28-39 | Franklin |
| 2021 | Division II | Christian Brothers (11-1) | 21-48 | Franklin |
| 2020 | Division II | Christian Brothers (18-2) | 22-46 | Franklin |
| 2020 | Class AAA | Wilson Central | 18-43 | Franklin |
| 2020 | Class A-AA | Fairview (36-7) | 26-42 | Franklin |
| 2019 | Division II | McCallie (10-5) | 32-36 | Franklin |
| 2019 | Class A-AA | Nolensville (37-10) | 18-59 | Franklin |
| 2019 | Class AAA | Bradley Central (26-7) | 9-56 | Franklin |
| 2018 | Division II | Baylor (14-3) | 28-32 | Franklin |
| 2018 | Class AAA | Science Hill (33-5) | 22-51 | Franklin |
| 2018 | Class A-AA | Signal Mountain (16-5) | 33-40 | Franklin |
| 2017 | Class A-AA | Greeneville | 26-41 | Franklin |
| 2017 | Class AAA | Cleveland | 24-35 | Franklin |
| 2017 | Division II | McCallie | 27-45 | Franklin |
| 2016 | Class AAA | Soddy-Daisy | 21-52 | Franklin |
| 2016 | Division II | Baylor | 22-36 | Franklin |
| 2016 | Class A-AA | Pigeon Forge | 30-34 | Franklin |
| 2015 | Division II | Father Ryan | 30-32 | Franklin |
| 2015 | Class A-AA | Hixson | 23-36 | Franklin |
| 2015 | Class AAA | Wilson Central | 26-35 | Franklin |
| 2014 | Class A-AA | Greeneville | 25-43 | Franklin |
| 2014 | Class AAA | Wilson Central | 15-50 | Franklin |
| 2014 | Division II | Father Ryan | 25-36 | Franklin |
| 2013 | Class AAA | Wilson Central | 4-78 | Franklin |
| 2013 | Class A-AA | Pigeon Forge | 34-36 | Franklin |
| 2013 | Division II | Father Ryan | 23-42 | Franklin |
| 2012 | Division II | Father Ryan | 22-41 | Franklin |
| 2012 | Class AAA | Cleveland | 22-29 | Franklin |
| 2012 | Class A-AA | Pigeon Forge | 27-33 | Franklin |
| 2011 | Division II | Christian Brothers | 25-27 | Franklin |
| 2011 | Class AAA | Soddy-Daisy | 15-44 | Franklin |
| 2011 | Class A-AA | Pigeon Forge | 26-30 | Franklin |
| 2010 | Division II | Christian Brothers | 24-28 | Franklin |
| 2010 | Class AAA | Cleveland | 28-33 | Franklin |
| 2010 | Class A-AA | East Literature | 36-41 | Franklin |
| 2009 | Division II | Father Ryan | 15-46 | Nashville |
| 2009 | Class AAA | Cleveland | 13-48 | Clarksville |
| 2009 | Class A-AA | Notre Dame | 28-32 | Clarksville |
| 2008 | Division II | Father Ryan | 24-36 | Nashville |
| 2008 | Class AAA | Ooltewah | 12-54 | Clarksville |
| 2008 | Class A-AA | Hixson | 27-31 | Clarksville |
| 2007 | Division II | Father Ryan | 23-35 | Clarksville |
| 2007 | Class AAA | Bradley Central | 23-35 | Clarksville |
| 2007 | Class A-AA | Seymour | 28-30 | Clarksville |
| 2006 | Division II | Baylor | 23-30 | Clarksville |
| 2006 | Class AAA | Clarksville | 30-31 | Clarksville |
| 2006 | Class A-AA | Franklin Road Academy | 23-48 | Clarksville |
| 2005 | Division II | McCallie | 25-31 | Clarksville |
| 2005 | Class AAA | Bradley Central | 31-32 | Clarksville |
| 2005 | Class A-AA | Springfield | 29-38 | Clarksville |
| 2004 | Division I | Soddy-Daisy | 22-38 | Clarksville |
| 2004 | Division II | McCallie | 27-35 | Clarksville |
| 2003 | Division I | Soddy-Daisy | 24-42 | Clarksville |
| 2003 | Division II | Father Ryan | 29-33 | Clarksville |
| 2002 | Division I | Bradley Central | 30-35 | Clarksville |
| 2002 | Division II | McCallie | 26-42 | Clarksville |
| 2001 | Division I | Clarksville | ||
| 2001 | Division II | Father Ryan | ||
| 2000 | Division I | Bradley Central | ||
| 2000 | Division II | Baylor | ||
| 1999 | Division II | Baylor | ||
| 1999 | Division I | Clarksville | ||
| 1998 | Division II | Baylor | ||
| 1998 | Division I | Brentwood | ||
| 1997 | Small | Page | ||
| 1997 | Large | Father Ryan | ||
| 1996 | Small | David Lipscomb | ||
| 1996 | Large | Baylor | ||
| 1995 | Small | Greeneville | ||
| 1995 | Large | Red Bank | ||
| 1994 | Small | Springfield | ||
| 1994 | Large | Father Ryan | ||
| 1993 | Small | Springfield | ||
| 1993 | Large | Bradley Central | ||
| 1992 | Small | Springfield | ||
| 1992 | Large | Baylor | ||
| 1991 | Large | Brentwood | ||
| 1991 | Small | Oakhaven | ||
| 1990 | Large | Knoxville Halls | ||
| 1990 | Small | Brentwood Academy | ||
| 1989 | Franklin | |||
| 1988 | McCallie |