| Year | Class | Team Fifth Place | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | Division I | Farragut | ||
| 2000 | Division II | Christian Brothers | ||
| 1999 | Division I | John Overton | ||
| 1999 | Division II | Christian Brothers | ||
| 1998 | Division I | Houston | ||
| 1998 | Division II | Notre Dame | ||
| 1997 | Large | Soddy-Daisy | ||
| 1997 | Small | Notre Dame | ||
| 1996 | Large | Germantown | ||
| 1996 | Small | Memphis University School | ||
| 1995 | Large | Karns | ||
| 1995 | Small | Marshall County | ||
| 1994 | Large | Germantown | ||
| 1994 | Small | David Lipscomb | ||
| 1993 | Large | Germantown | ||
| 1993 | Small | East Ridge | ||
| 1992 | Large | Germantown | ||
| 1992 | Small | Chattanooga Central |